[nycphp-talk] About Formalizing an Enterprise PHP and the PHP+Developer
Kristina Anderson
ka at kacomputerconsulting.com
Wed Apr 23 22:21:43 EDT 2008
Really hope the questions about Left Outer Joins using COALESCE and how
to get mail() to work on a Windows box aren't on the cert test??
Or I'm doo doo. :)
PS I'm not sure how to say "fogged a mirror" in Latin but we can look
it up!
> on 2008-04-23 17:25 Peter Sawczynec said the following:
> > I believe the most beneficial PHP+ cert that we can strive for
would be
> > more on par with a Cisco cert. An acknowledged, industry heavy
weight,
>
> Note that the lower-level Cisco certs (i.e. everything but the CCIE
or
> its equivalent) now have a multitude of boot-camps available for them
to
> push you through in a weekend, and therefore their value, both real
and
> perceived, is slipping. It's been a while since I've studied the
finer
> trivia of Cisco kit, but I'm confident I could muster a passing score
> all the way up to CCNP without studying for more than a weekend--a
week,
> tops. Would you let me loose on your routers *only* knowing *that*?
(The
> fact that I deal with Cisco kit in other ways on a daily basis
> notwithstanding...)
>
> What makes the CCIE so valuable is that it contains both a written
and a
> lab component, and the latter is damn *hard* -- it has a real failure
> rate in the double digits -- so that it's unlikely that you'll be
able
> to pass it through book learning alone. That is to say: in order to
pass
> it, you're most likely an experienced practitioner already.
>
> I see a lot of talk about certifications, and I have to reiterate the
> question: why bother? In other words, what are you trying to
accomplish?
> In order for it to really fulfill its mission, a certification
basically
> needs to substantiate someone's years of experience and actual
ability
> to perform: it's a *certification* that you can *do something* that
> isn't just your word for it, and it comes from an impartial third
party
> (whoever they may be).
>
> Of course, it matters a bit who the certifying authority is (which is
> why people value degrees from real colleges over mail-order degrees),
> but unless there is a statutory requirement for licensure and
> registration, the only value of the certification "in the
marketplace"
> is what the holders are actually doing: if you've got a certificate
that
> is, in a word, achievable in a week's intensive course, it's
worthless
> except to paper collectors, and the market will value the
certification
> accordingly.
>
> > difficult but well worth while cert. I believe that the cert should
be
> > advanced, sophisticated and relatively difficult -- the PHP+ cert
should
> > not be about qualifying entry-level initiates, it would be used for
> > qualifying middle to expert level.
>
> Peter has successfully compiled the correct here. I would take it
> further: the exam should be QUITE difficult, and dilettantes should
NOT
> be able to pass it.
>
> Make a certification more like the PE, where you must show verifiable
> years of experience (signed off by another in the field), and have a
> tough exam on top of that (and I'm not even counting the EIT), or
more
> like the CCIE, with a very difficult pair of exams, *written and
> practical*, and then you'd have a certification that is worth
bandying
> about--something that conveys the elusive "I should get paid more
> because I'm *demonstrably* worth it" message.
>
> Oh yes, it should also need to be renewed every 7 years or so, not
just
> to generate income for the certifying authority, but to demonstrate
that
> you're still at the level you claim to be.
>
> > There could/should be a separate entry-level cert if needed.
>
> Given the field of programming, I would suggest the "fog a mirror"
> certification. For $29.95, I'll provide you with a certificate
suitable
> for framing. For $39.95, I'll even make it 3 color. (Latin available
> upon request, and only to Kristina.)
>
> > Peter
>
> //jbaltz
> --
> jerry b. altzman jbaltz at altzman.com www.jbaltz.com
> thank you for contributing to the heat death of the universe.
> _______________________________________________
> New York PHP Community Talk Mailing List
> http://lists.nyphp.org/mailman/listinfo/talk
>
> NYPHPCon 2006 Presentations Online
> http://www.nyphpcon.com
>
> Show Your Participation in New York PHP
> http://www.nyphp.org/show_participation.php
>
More information about the talk
mailing list